Topic: Plea bargaining is unjust
affirmative:
-compromising the defendant's sentence is unfair (same crime may have two different punishments)
-provides a motivation for criminal to lie about involvement of others
-not a fair chance (not everyone is offered a plea bargain)
-too many options to insure justice in every case (it's better to have people in jail with too long of a sentence than with one too short)
-victim has already had choice in deciding whether to do crime or not (does not deserve another one)
negative:
-saves money and time for courts (can allocate resources for important cases)
-could provide information about involvement of others (lead to more justice)
-reward for remorseful defendants
-gives them an option (everyone makes mistakes)
-better to have guilty people on a shorter sentence than guilty people going free
so... if you have articles or ideas or speeches post them in response to this!
Friday, November 30, 2007
Wednesday, November 28, 2007
English Paper- On the Waterfront
On the Waterfront Film Analysis
On the Waterfront, directed by Elia Kazan, is effective as a film, if slightly overdramatic, by utilizing the literary, dramatic, and cinematic elements that compose this medium. Symbolism, a literary element, is used throughout the movie, even in idle chatting scenes between Edie and Terry: “You know this city's full of hawks? That's a fact. They hang around on the top of the big hotels. And they spot a pigeon in the park. Right down on him”. Dramatic elements such as acting are obviously high quality in the film, as it won Best Actor in Leading Role and Best Actress in a Supporting Role as well as three nominations for Best Actor in a Supporting Role at the Oscars for 1955. Cinematic elements also added to the film’s effectiveness, although the music was a little overly dramatic. On the Waterfront may have a few faults, but it is a truly effective film
One literary aspect used effectively in On the Waterfront was symbols. Throughout the film, different sorts of birds are used to represent groups of people and their relationships to each other. The situation of the pigeons describes especially well the plight of the longshoremen workers. In several scenes, one views the pigeons trapped in their wire cages, which, although provide them with protection from the hawks, also limit the pigeons freedom. One even questions the protection they provide as in the end it is the cages themselves that allow Terry’s young protégé to kill them so systematically. The cages function in relation to the pigeons much as the union functions in relation to the longshoremen. Originally, the union was meant to be protection for the workers, and although it limited their economic freedom slightly by requiring them to pay union dues, it also protected them from being abused by the companies. However, much as the cages backfire for the pigeons, the union actually is the cause of the abuse and fear in which the longshoremen are forced to live in. Both the pigeons and the workers are both in similar difficult situations resulting from their captivity.
Theme is another literary aspect integral to On the Waterfront. The importance of self-worth is made clear throughout the film as Terry Malloy struggles to ensure that he is not “a bum”. At the beginning of the film, he doesn’t have a very high opinion of himself after the quick end to his boxing career as brought about by his brother: “I coulda had class. I coulda been a contender. I coulda been somebody, instead of a bum, which is what I am, let's face it.” Even after he has testified before the court as to the illegal activities of Johnny Friendly and avenged his brother’s death, he still does not feel complete or at peace with himself. He is drawn down to the waterfront, where the exclusion of the other dockworkers obviously affects him deeply, causing him to go down and challenge Johnny Friendly. Even with the progress he has made against the mob in favor of the workers, Terry doesn’t yet feel as if he has earned the respect he craves, and his treatment of the longshoremen simply reaffirms this for him. Even though he loses the fight, his confrontation with Johnny Friendly shows how Terry has truly grown since the beginning of the film, where he was willing to betray someone who he would call a friend. Now, he is backing up his claim to take down Johnny Friendly. His status alteration in the eyes of the workers is evident as they ignore Johnny’s commands to return to work, even pushing him in the water. However, the event that truly transforms Terry seems to be his walk to the warehouse. Especially significant is the Father’s specification that he makes it alone. He is showing his self-worth in this moment, earning for himself. As he yells to Johnny, distancing himself from that group: “You think you’re God Almighty, but you know what you are? You’re a cheap, lousy, dirty, stinkin’ mug!” By succeeding without the help and guidance of others, Terry can finally have some respect for himself; show that he is not “a bum”.
Dramatic aspects are also effective in On the Waterfront. Costumes are one element that is used symbolically to provide a better understanding of the characters. Terry’s various coats show his affiliations throughout the film. In the beginning, Terry is wearing his plaid coat, which, although it is not as nice as the coats worn by the higher ranked mob members, it does distinguish him from the other longshoremen, seeming slightly nicer, more styled. After he begins to spend more time with Edie, and he defends Father Barry at Dugan’s death, Edie offers him Joey’s old coat, showing his conversion to the side of the workers, as well as the line of previous owners as “canaries” that he is going to follow. Another costume item that lends insight into the characters is something so insignificant, it is easy to miss: the blood dripping from Father Barry’s head as he presides over Dugan’s death. This small trivial line that appears on his head after being hit by a can shows his true dedication to the workers: instead of hiding within his church as Edie accuses him of at the beginning of the film, he is risking himself for their cause. He proceeds to deliver a rousing speech, and Terry himself protects the Father from his supposed mob comrades. In a way, the blood from Father Barry’s head shows the conversion of both himself and Terry to the side of the workers. Obviously, props are a significant dramatic aspect in On the Waterfront.
Another dramatic element used to great effect in the film in acting. Although not an extremely likeable character, Eva Marie Saint does an excellent job portraying Edie Doyle in On the Waterfront. Edie plays a remarkably significant role in the fight against the union mob, yet Eva Marie Saint ensures that she seems delicate and prone to a breakdown at the same time. Edie convinces Father Barry to become involved in his community by scrabbling for a token for her father; she convinces Terry to forsake his brother and testify in front of a court; she refuses to return to school because she wishes to discover the truth about her brother’s death; she even supports Terry at the end as he makes his walk up to the door to start the workers on a new era of fair employment. However, Edie simultaneously seems like a delicate creature, helpless against the fervor of Terry, unable to call out his name as he stalks down the alley almost to his death. Although this fragileness becomes slightly irritating at times, Eva Marie Saint’s unfaltering balancing act of Edie’s faint nature and capable acts is impressive.
Lee J. Cobb is another actor who does a tremendous job playing Johnny Friendly, the mob boss. Although the villain in On the Waterfront, Cobb gives a sense of dignity to Friendly, providing a background and a motivation for his despicable behavior. At the beginning of the film, as Johnny tries to ensure Terry’s loyalty in the pool room at his bar, his speech about his rise from the bottom to the top is oddly persuasive, the phrase “If we can, we are entitled to it” sticking in one’s head. Another particularly effective scene is after the trial as Johnny and his gang return to the union house, as Cobb shows Johnny’s frustration as he sees no way out of this mess, his childlike technique of taking out his anger on the ineptitude of his men. Overall, Lee J. Cobb portrays skillfully the complete Johnny Friendly character, both the positive and the negative.
The main character in On the Waterfront, Terry Malloy, has become one the most well known characters in film history due to the epic performance by Marlon Brando. Brando captures the conflicted emotions that Terry is feeling so well that even someone who has never been in a situation of the same degree feels a connection to him. A few scenes affix themselves in one’s mind due to Brando’s representation. One scene, when Terry takes Edie out for a drink, is a light-hearted scene with darker aspects that comes across clearly. Brando shows the tension within Terry, between his attraction to Edie and care for her, and his guilt over her brother’s death, by the awkwardness in which the conversation progresses between the two of them. Rude comments by Terry make the audience cringe, but one does not feel anger at Terry for his inconsiderateness; instead, the viewer can see this is Terry’s attempt at helping Edie cope with her brother’s death and his own attempt at assuage his conscience. Brando skillful combination of earnest looks and artless comments portray this clearly for the spectator. The scene of the fight and Terry’s eventual triumph over Johnny Friendly is another that adheres to one’s mind because of Brando’s performance. This success by Terry, which has been expected from the beginning of the movie, could have turned out extremely badly: more of a cheesy affair than anything else. However, Brando keeps the audience absorbed by the determination with which Terry withstands the obvious pain and the independence which he gains as he walks by himself to the warehouse. The power of this scene is definitely due to Brando’s stirring performance.
Cinematic aspects are the final piece of the puzzle in On the Waterfront. Shadow is used effectively in the scene of Dugan’s death, as the net used to haul up the crates (the cause of the death) cast a shadow over the crowd assembled to pay their respect. It is interesting to note that this net doesn’t cast a shadow, or the blame, just on the mob members who arranged Dugan’s death, but on his friends and the people who cared about him. This effect shows how, by not reporting the crimes of the union, everyone present is in some way responsible for the demise of Dugan. Alternately, one could see the nets shadow as representative of the plight of the workers, as they are trapped by the mob member much the way Dugan was. Shadow is used extremely effectively in this scene. Another cinematic element used well in the film was the angle of shots. In the first scene, after Terry stops by Joey’s house to send him to the roof, one views the building through a low angle. This has a two-fold effect: it gives an ominous and powerful feel to the building and the actions of the mob, and builds suspense as to the events transpiring up on the roof, as the viewer is unable to see the action and can only hear the sounds. A high angle shot is also used to great effect in the scene at the docks as the boss chooses the workers for the day. After selecting the ones that he wishes to work, he scatters the tokens on the ground and the men go crazy. A high angle shot is used during this scene, portraying the men on the ground fighting for the tokens as low, almost pig-like, without respect for themselves as they are willing to scrabble around on the ground, much to the amusement of the mob members. The viewer is repulsed by the spectacle of grown men with so little self-respect and the lack of pity by the union. A third cinematic aspect in On the Waterfront is the use of sound, specifically in the scene where Terry confesses to Edie his role in the death of her brother. Although the camera focuses quite clearly on their heated discussion, one can only hear snippets of the conversation, mostly of Edie’s grief. The loud sounds of business of the waterfront, of the cranes and barges doing their work as usual primarily cover up the exchange between the two main characters, which may seem rather odd. However, one gets the sense in this scene that this struggle between what’s right and what seems easiest is not one that pertains only to Edie and Terry; instead, with the obnoxious sounds of the waterfront work, one is reminded that this conflict is being played out in everyone of the workers mind. In a sense, the specific words that Terry uses, or exactly how Edie expresses her grief: these details are not important. By omitting them, one can apply this clash of ethics to many people and many situations on the waterfront.
Much as On the Waterfront deals with the personal and public effects of a moral decision, Arthur Miller’s play All My Sons explores the multiple obligations one has both to family and to strangers. The main characters, Terry and Chris, share many similarities. Firstly, both Terry and Chris struggle to decide which party they have more loyalty to: those they know the best, or strangers. In Chris’ case, his father is the one that he has esteemed all his life. However, he also feels that the mothers of these dead soldiers have some right to know the cause of their child’s death. Unfortunately, Chris’ own mother convolutes this matter more by urging Chris not to turn his father in, even after her own son has perished in the war. Terry has a similar situation in that he is torn between his obligation to two groups: to the mob, which not only contains his brother but also a childhood mentor of his, Johnny Friendly (“He used to take me to ball-games”), and to his community as a whole, which would benefit greatly without the mob running the union. To complicate Terry’s decision, the only way that he could truly put and end to the illegal mob activity would be to go to the police, an action frowned upon by the community, so that in helping them, he would be earning their disapproval. Secondly, both characters maintain the added complication of a forbidden love. Terry is wooing Edie, the sister of the man whose death is on his conscience. Chris proposes to his dead brother’s girlfriend, Annie. Both of them use these leading women in their lives to help them make the right decision: Annie and Edie act as moral compasses. Thirdly, after both Chris and Terry chose the “hard way” regarding their ethical decisions, they experience both a win and a loss regarding their choices. Chris finds the internal strength to confront his father, who admits he is wrong. He, with the help of Annie, forces his mother to realize that she must forget the past. However, in the process his father feels forced to commit suicide, which is a terrible loss for Chris. Terry, after testifying in court, does not feel satisfied with his success. Instead, he seeks out Johnny Friendly to prove to him the man he is the “waterfront” way. Although he loses the fistfight to Johnny, becoming badly beaten up, he also wins the workers over to his side, which is evident as they refuse Johnny’s demands that they return to work and wait until their comrade Terry is with them. Both Terry from On the Waterfront and Chris from All My Sons share many aspects regarding their loyalties on a tough ethical decision.
Overall, the film On the Waterfront is an effective film. So much detail was paid upon the smallest things, adding to the depth of the film. It skillfully combined literary aspects such as symbolism in small things like props and costumes without weighing down the film, as it was still enjoyable to watch. The variety of shots used truly added to the impression upon the viewer, making the film more interesting and adding to one’s understanding of the characters. Terry was an enjoyable character to watch in that he wasn’t perfect, not even close. He was an awkward individual when it came to romancing Edie, he struggled to decide where his loyalties lay, yet in the end he triumphed. The famous scene where he makes his stand to his brother Charley is particularly affecting because Terry hasn’t truly shown and inclination to stand up for either side before this point, yet here his is convincing his brother to go to his own death. Another powerful (if slightly overemotional) scene was the walk from the union house to the loading dock, because even though Terry had lost, he won. He prevailed against Johnny Friendly, even when his community was not supporting him. My only criticism would be that the film was rather overly dramatic, with much of it seeming musical-like. Although in some aspects this may increase the effectiveness of a production, in this case I felt that it detracted from the film’s emotional appeal, as it made the characters and their struggles seem staged and harder to relate to. However, because of several stellar scenes I would have to say that On the Waterfront is an effective film in getting it’s message across.
On the Waterfront, directed by Elia Kazan, is effective as a film, if slightly overdramatic, by utilizing the literary, dramatic, and cinematic elements that compose this medium. Symbolism, a literary element, is used throughout the movie, even in idle chatting scenes between Edie and Terry: “You know this city's full of hawks? That's a fact. They hang around on the top of the big hotels. And they spot a pigeon in the park. Right down on him”. Dramatic elements such as acting are obviously high quality in the film, as it won Best Actor in Leading Role and Best Actress in a Supporting Role as well as three nominations for Best Actor in a Supporting Role at the Oscars for 1955. Cinematic elements also added to the film’s effectiveness, although the music was a little overly dramatic. On the Waterfront may have a few faults, but it is a truly effective film
One literary aspect used effectively in On the Waterfront was symbols. Throughout the film, different sorts of birds are used to represent groups of people and their relationships to each other. The situation of the pigeons describes especially well the plight of the longshoremen workers. In several scenes, one views the pigeons trapped in their wire cages, which, although provide them with protection from the hawks, also limit the pigeons freedom. One even questions the protection they provide as in the end it is the cages themselves that allow Terry’s young protégé to kill them so systematically. The cages function in relation to the pigeons much as the union functions in relation to the longshoremen. Originally, the union was meant to be protection for the workers, and although it limited their economic freedom slightly by requiring them to pay union dues, it also protected them from being abused by the companies. However, much as the cages backfire for the pigeons, the union actually is the cause of the abuse and fear in which the longshoremen are forced to live in. Both the pigeons and the workers are both in similar difficult situations resulting from their captivity.
Theme is another literary aspect integral to On the Waterfront. The importance of self-worth is made clear throughout the film as Terry Malloy struggles to ensure that he is not “a bum”. At the beginning of the film, he doesn’t have a very high opinion of himself after the quick end to his boxing career as brought about by his brother: “I coulda had class. I coulda been a contender. I coulda been somebody, instead of a bum, which is what I am, let's face it.” Even after he has testified before the court as to the illegal activities of Johnny Friendly and avenged his brother’s death, he still does not feel complete or at peace with himself. He is drawn down to the waterfront, where the exclusion of the other dockworkers obviously affects him deeply, causing him to go down and challenge Johnny Friendly. Even with the progress he has made against the mob in favor of the workers, Terry doesn’t yet feel as if he has earned the respect he craves, and his treatment of the longshoremen simply reaffirms this for him. Even though he loses the fight, his confrontation with Johnny Friendly shows how Terry has truly grown since the beginning of the film, where he was willing to betray someone who he would call a friend. Now, he is backing up his claim to take down Johnny Friendly. His status alteration in the eyes of the workers is evident as they ignore Johnny’s commands to return to work, even pushing him in the water. However, the event that truly transforms Terry seems to be his walk to the warehouse. Especially significant is the Father’s specification that he makes it alone. He is showing his self-worth in this moment, earning for himself. As he yells to Johnny, distancing himself from that group: “You think you’re God Almighty, but you know what you are? You’re a cheap, lousy, dirty, stinkin’ mug!” By succeeding without the help and guidance of others, Terry can finally have some respect for himself; show that he is not “a bum”.
Dramatic aspects are also effective in On the Waterfront. Costumes are one element that is used symbolically to provide a better understanding of the characters. Terry’s various coats show his affiliations throughout the film. In the beginning, Terry is wearing his plaid coat, which, although it is not as nice as the coats worn by the higher ranked mob members, it does distinguish him from the other longshoremen, seeming slightly nicer, more styled. After he begins to spend more time with Edie, and he defends Father Barry at Dugan’s death, Edie offers him Joey’s old coat, showing his conversion to the side of the workers, as well as the line of previous owners as “canaries” that he is going to follow. Another costume item that lends insight into the characters is something so insignificant, it is easy to miss: the blood dripping from Father Barry’s head as he presides over Dugan’s death. This small trivial line that appears on his head after being hit by a can shows his true dedication to the workers: instead of hiding within his church as Edie accuses him of at the beginning of the film, he is risking himself for their cause. He proceeds to deliver a rousing speech, and Terry himself protects the Father from his supposed mob comrades. In a way, the blood from Father Barry’s head shows the conversion of both himself and Terry to the side of the workers. Obviously, props are a significant dramatic aspect in On the Waterfront.
Another dramatic element used to great effect in the film in acting. Although not an extremely likeable character, Eva Marie Saint does an excellent job portraying Edie Doyle in On the Waterfront. Edie plays a remarkably significant role in the fight against the union mob, yet Eva Marie Saint ensures that she seems delicate and prone to a breakdown at the same time. Edie convinces Father Barry to become involved in his community by scrabbling for a token for her father; she convinces Terry to forsake his brother and testify in front of a court; she refuses to return to school because she wishes to discover the truth about her brother’s death; she even supports Terry at the end as he makes his walk up to the door to start the workers on a new era of fair employment. However, Edie simultaneously seems like a delicate creature, helpless against the fervor of Terry, unable to call out his name as he stalks down the alley almost to his death. Although this fragileness becomes slightly irritating at times, Eva Marie Saint’s unfaltering balancing act of Edie’s faint nature and capable acts is impressive.
Lee J. Cobb is another actor who does a tremendous job playing Johnny Friendly, the mob boss. Although the villain in On the Waterfront, Cobb gives a sense of dignity to Friendly, providing a background and a motivation for his despicable behavior. At the beginning of the film, as Johnny tries to ensure Terry’s loyalty in the pool room at his bar, his speech about his rise from the bottom to the top is oddly persuasive, the phrase “If we can, we are entitled to it” sticking in one’s head. Another particularly effective scene is after the trial as Johnny and his gang return to the union house, as Cobb shows Johnny’s frustration as he sees no way out of this mess, his childlike technique of taking out his anger on the ineptitude of his men. Overall, Lee J. Cobb portrays skillfully the complete Johnny Friendly character, both the positive and the negative.
The main character in On the Waterfront, Terry Malloy, has become one the most well known characters in film history due to the epic performance by Marlon Brando. Brando captures the conflicted emotions that Terry is feeling so well that even someone who has never been in a situation of the same degree feels a connection to him. A few scenes affix themselves in one’s mind due to Brando’s representation. One scene, when Terry takes Edie out for a drink, is a light-hearted scene with darker aspects that comes across clearly. Brando shows the tension within Terry, between his attraction to Edie and care for her, and his guilt over her brother’s death, by the awkwardness in which the conversation progresses between the two of them. Rude comments by Terry make the audience cringe, but one does not feel anger at Terry for his inconsiderateness; instead, the viewer can see this is Terry’s attempt at helping Edie cope with her brother’s death and his own attempt at assuage his conscience. Brando skillful combination of earnest looks and artless comments portray this clearly for the spectator. The scene of the fight and Terry’s eventual triumph over Johnny Friendly is another that adheres to one’s mind because of Brando’s performance. This success by Terry, which has been expected from the beginning of the movie, could have turned out extremely badly: more of a cheesy affair than anything else. However, Brando keeps the audience absorbed by the determination with which Terry withstands the obvious pain and the independence which he gains as he walks by himself to the warehouse. The power of this scene is definitely due to Brando’s stirring performance.
Cinematic aspects are the final piece of the puzzle in On the Waterfront. Shadow is used effectively in the scene of Dugan’s death, as the net used to haul up the crates (the cause of the death) cast a shadow over the crowd assembled to pay their respect. It is interesting to note that this net doesn’t cast a shadow, or the blame, just on the mob members who arranged Dugan’s death, but on his friends and the people who cared about him. This effect shows how, by not reporting the crimes of the union, everyone present is in some way responsible for the demise of Dugan. Alternately, one could see the nets shadow as representative of the plight of the workers, as they are trapped by the mob member much the way Dugan was. Shadow is used extremely effectively in this scene. Another cinematic element used well in the film was the angle of shots. In the first scene, after Terry stops by Joey’s house to send him to the roof, one views the building through a low angle. This has a two-fold effect: it gives an ominous and powerful feel to the building and the actions of the mob, and builds suspense as to the events transpiring up on the roof, as the viewer is unable to see the action and can only hear the sounds. A high angle shot is also used to great effect in the scene at the docks as the boss chooses the workers for the day. After selecting the ones that he wishes to work, he scatters the tokens on the ground and the men go crazy. A high angle shot is used during this scene, portraying the men on the ground fighting for the tokens as low, almost pig-like, without respect for themselves as they are willing to scrabble around on the ground, much to the amusement of the mob members. The viewer is repulsed by the spectacle of grown men with so little self-respect and the lack of pity by the union. A third cinematic aspect in On the Waterfront is the use of sound, specifically in the scene where Terry confesses to Edie his role in the death of her brother. Although the camera focuses quite clearly on their heated discussion, one can only hear snippets of the conversation, mostly of Edie’s grief. The loud sounds of business of the waterfront, of the cranes and barges doing their work as usual primarily cover up the exchange between the two main characters, which may seem rather odd. However, one gets the sense in this scene that this struggle between what’s right and what seems easiest is not one that pertains only to Edie and Terry; instead, with the obnoxious sounds of the waterfront work, one is reminded that this conflict is being played out in everyone of the workers mind. In a sense, the specific words that Terry uses, or exactly how Edie expresses her grief: these details are not important. By omitting them, one can apply this clash of ethics to many people and many situations on the waterfront.
Much as On the Waterfront deals with the personal and public effects of a moral decision, Arthur Miller’s play All My Sons explores the multiple obligations one has both to family and to strangers. The main characters, Terry and Chris, share many similarities. Firstly, both Terry and Chris struggle to decide which party they have more loyalty to: those they know the best, or strangers. In Chris’ case, his father is the one that he has esteemed all his life. However, he also feels that the mothers of these dead soldiers have some right to know the cause of their child’s death. Unfortunately, Chris’ own mother convolutes this matter more by urging Chris not to turn his father in, even after her own son has perished in the war. Terry has a similar situation in that he is torn between his obligation to two groups: to the mob, which not only contains his brother but also a childhood mentor of his, Johnny Friendly (“He used to take me to ball-games”), and to his community as a whole, which would benefit greatly without the mob running the union. To complicate Terry’s decision, the only way that he could truly put and end to the illegal mob activity would be to go to the police, an action frowned upon by the community, so that in helping them, he would be earning their disapproval. Secondly, both characters maintain the added complication of a forbidden love. Terry is wooing Edie, the sister of the man whose death is on his conscience. Chris proposes to his dead brother’s girlfriend, Annie. Both of them use these leading women in their lives to help them make the right decision: Annie and Edie act as moral compasses. Thirdly, after both Chris and Terry chose the “hard way” regarding their ethical decisions, they experience both a win and a loss regarding their choices. Chris finds the internal strength to confront his father, who admits he is wrong. He, with the help of Annie, forces his mother to realize that she must forget the past. However, in the process his father feels forced to commit suicide, which is a terrible loss for Chris. Terry, after testifying in court, does not feel satisfied with his success. Instead, he seeks out Johnny Friendly to prove to him the man he is the “waterfront” way. Although he loses the fistfight to Johnny, becoming badly beaten up, he also wins the workers over to his side, which is evident as they refuse Johnny’s demands that they return to work and wait until their comrade Terry is with them. Both Terry from On the Waterfront and Chris from All My Sons share many aspects regarding their loyalties on a tough ethical decision.
Overall, the film On the Waterfront is an effective film. So much detail was paid upon the smallest things, adding to the depth of the film. It skillfully combined literary aspects such as symbolism in small things like props and costumes without weighing down the film, as it was still enjoyable to watch. The variety of shots used truly added to the impression upon the viewer, making the film more interesting and adding to one’s understanding of the characters. Terry was an enjoyable character to watch in that he wasn’t perfect, not even close. He was an awkward individual when it came to romancing Edie, he struggled to decide where his loyalties lay, yet in the end he triumphed. The famous scene where he makes his stand to his brother Charley is particularly affecting because Terry hasn’t truly shown and inclination to stand up for either side before this point, yet here his is convincing his brother to go to his own death. Another powerful (if slightly overemotional) scene was the walk from the union house to the loading dock, because even though Terry had lost, he won. He prevailed against Johnny Friendly, even when his community was not supporting him. My only criticism would be that the film was rather overly dramatic, with much of it seeming musical-like. Although in some aspects this may increase the effectiveness of a production, in this case I felt that it detracted from the film’s emotional appeal, as it made the characters and their struggles seem staged and harder to relate to. However, because of several stellar scenes I would have to say that On the Waterfront is an effective film in getting it’s message across.
"Special Topics" Post 3b
I am becoming slightly disturbed by Blue’s behavior. First of all, she doesn’t see it strange that the Bluebloods practically stalk Hannah. This behavior goes directly against her wishes, so I’m not really sure if they respect her or not. I think there’s just a lot of conflict as to the role of Hannah. On one hand, she is an adult and a teacher at their school, so one should think of her as an authority figure. On the other hand, she acts sometimes less like a mentor and more of a simple friend. I think that it is hard for the Bluebloods to reconcile these two roles, and are therefore acting as if they are Hannah’s friends. Unfortunately, I don’t think that she views them this way. Plus, Blue is being dragged into this as well. She seems content with the changes she has been making to herself to fit in with the group, but her writing suggests otherwise, as it is an odd mixture of talk of the Bluebloods and references to her father. I think that she is still torn between the two. Ordinarily, I would say that it is natural for Blue to grow away from her father and find her own group, but in all the towns they have been to this doesn’t seem to have been the case. This change is so unexpected I feel it’s not quite natural. Hopefully Blue will find which side she wishes to be on in the remainder of the book.
Tuesday, November 27, 2007
"Special Topics" Post 3a
Vocabulary
hebetudinous (161): the state of having dullness of mind, mental lethargy
Marlene Dietrich (160): German-born American actress and singer (1904-1992), internationally famous as a film star
Literary Devices
"a revolted expression spilled all over her face" (141): The author uses the verb "spilled" to better describe how a look of disgust unfolded onto Leulah's face as she got her first good look at "Doc".
"We were stationed somewhere, oceans away from home, afraid of being seen. Leulah was shell-shocked, back straight as a flag pole, her eyes magnetized to the door. Jade was the senior officer... I sort of Vietnamed too" (144): This analogy of comparing the girls witnessing Hannah and "Doc" and men surviving the atrocities of Vietnam shows the effect that this event has had on them, how deeply it has influenced them. Even the simile showing Leulah's disbelief: "back as straight as a flag pole" connects to this idea of surviving a war.
"We all went forward and backward together like children on a bus" (156): Although this simile does well describe the phenomenon that occurs when someone slams on the breaks in a car, it also could be interpreted as the author commenting on the child-likeness nature of the prank the Bluebloods are about to pull: sneaking into Hannah's party.
Quote
"...Dad's favorite ("If there are authentic words of love that exist in this English language, these are the ones people with any real affection should say, rather than the shopworn, 'I love you,' which can be uttered by any hebetudinous Tom, Dick, or Moe")" (161). This quote shows the haughtiness and high standards that Blue's father has in almost everything, as well as his pride in his literary knowledge. However, it also shows the respect that Blue has for her father by including a quote that might pertain to Hannah, who she seems to hold in very high regard.
Theme
Don't try and investigate something that is none of your business.
hebetudinous (161): the state of having dullness of mind, mental lethargy
Marlene Dietrich (160): German-born American actress and singer (1904-1992), internationally famous as a film star
Literary Devices
"a revolted expression spilled all over her face" (141): The author uses the verb "spilled" to better describe how a look of disgust unfolded onto Leulah's face as she got her first good look at "Doc".
"We were stationed somewhere, oceans away from home, afraid of being seen. Leulah was shell-shocked, back straight as a flag pole, her eyes magnetized to the door. Jade was the senior officer... I sort of Vietnamed too" (144): This analogy of comparing the girls witnessing Hannah and "Doc" and men surviving the atrocities of Vietnam shows the effect that this event has had on them, how deeply it has influenced them. Even the simile showing Leulah's disbelief: "back as straight as a flag pole" connects to this idea of surviving a war.
"We all went forward and backward together like children on a bus" (156): Although this simile does well describe the phenomenon that occurs when someone slams on the breaks in a car, it also could be interpreted as the author commenting on the child-likeness nature of the prank the Bluebloods are about to pull: sneaking into Hannah's party.
Quote
"...Dad's favorite ("If there are authentic words of love that exist in this English language, these are the ones people with any real affection should say, rather than the shopworn, 'I love you,' which can be uttered by any hebetudinous Tom, Dick, or Moe")" (161). This quote shows the haughtiness and high standards that Blue's father has in almost everything, as well as his pride in his literary knowledge. However, it also shows the respect that Blue has for her father by including a quote that might pertain to Hannah, who she seems to hold in very high regard.
Theme
Don't try and investigate something that is none of your business.
Monday, November 19, 2007
"Special Topics" Post 2b
In this section of “Special Topics in Calamity Physics”, we begin to witness the transformation of Blue from a wall-flower geek to a member of the Bluebloods, and while I found it extremely satisfying to see her get the respect that she deserves, the ease in which she gives up her personality and conforms to expectations that Leulah and Jade have for her is a little disturbing. In some ways, its showing how Blue is growing independent from her father, which is only natural, and experimenting with how she wants to be perceived. However, when reading the book I feel as if Blue looks up to Jade and Leulah a bit too much and that they could easily abuse this power, which I don’t think they deserve. As Blue says, “being snubbed at Hannah’s was infinitely more electrifying than being mulled over back at the Van Meers” (94). Additionally, however overly condescending, monopolizing, and judgmental Blue’s father is, one has to feel a little sad for him as he is constantly being left behind by his daughter. He must feel a little confused, as not only her appearance changes dramatically but also her values. Before, Blue was focused on the idea of getting in to Harvard; she even snubs Charles in the beginning because she doesn’t want anything interfering with her senior year. This does seem a little extreme, and I hope Blue has fun with the Bluebloods, but I hope she doesn’t lose sight of herself and the future.
Sunday, November 18, 2007
"Special Topics" Post 2a
Vocabulary
crampons (97): a spiked iron or steel framework that is attached to the bottom of the shoe; used in climbing on ice or snow
Golighty [dress] (111): alluding to the style of clothing worn by Hepburn in her role as Holly Golightly from "Breakfast at Tiffany's"
Figurative language
Personification: "The same word, when you said it, went limp" (94). Blue is explaining the power over words that Hannah has; her way with intonation that makes the same wordd, when another says it, seem much more dull. The words are not actually goign limp, they just do not have the same electrifying effect as when Hannah speaks them.
Allusion: "'Maybe it's her Rosebud.'" (104). Blue is referencing the movie "Citizen Kane", in which Kane spends his entire life looking for Rosebud. This gives the reader a sense of the depth of Hannah's fixation for Valerio that has been impressed on Blue, as well as her extensive knowledge.
Simile: "'It's fun to imagine they're as epidemic as illiteracy or chronic fatigue or any other cultural malaise that graces the covers of Time and Newsweek, but sadly, most Bob Joneses off the street are just that, Bob Jones'" (105). This simile (which one can tell from the use of the word as to compare the numbers of double lives and other cultural deficiencies) shows that Blue's father doubts her theory on the double life that Hannah leads, and also demonstrates his ideas of problems in society (illiteracy, etc.)
Quote
"Frankly, it could get a little stale how Dad, within minutes, could elicit such worldwide acclaim. Sure- I was the first person to stand up and throw him roses, shout, "Bravo, man, bravo!" But sometimes I couldn't help but feel Dad was an opera diva who garnered reverential ratings even when he was too lazy to higt the high notes...; something about him seized everyone, regardless of the performance" (112). I really liked this quote because it shows a lot of Blue's character. She really seems to rely upon her father almost has her star to pull out for others to admire, and so she takes a rather protective stance on his praise in the quote as if she is the only one she can stand doing it. It also shows that she perhaps isn't completely happy just being his daughter, instead of her own character, her own star.
Theme
Sometimes one must delve deeper to find the truth.
crampons (97): a spiked iron or steel framework that is attached to the bottom of the shoe; used in climbing on ice or snow
Golighty [dress] (111): alluding to the style of clothing worn by Hepburn in her role as Holly Golightly from "Breakfast at Tiffany's"
Figurative language
Personification: "The same word, when you said it, went limp" (94). Blue is explaining the power over words that Hannah has; her way with intonation that makes the same wordd, when another says it, seem much more dull. The words are not actually goign limp, they just do not have the same electrifying effect as when Hannah speaks them.
Allusion: "'Maybe it's her Rosebud.'" (104). Blue is referencing the movie "Citizen Kane", in which Kane spends his entire life looking for Rosebud. This gives the reader a sense of the depth of Hannah's fixation for Valerio that has been impressed on Blue, as well as her extensive knowledge.
Simile: "'It's fun to imagine they're as epidemic as illiteracy or chronic fatigue or any other cultural malaise that graces the covers of Time and Newsweek, but sadly, most Bob Joneses off the street are just that, Bob Jones'" (105). This simile (which one can tell from the use of the word as to compare the numbers of double lives and other cultural deficiencies) shows that Blue's father doubts her theory on the double life that Hannah leads, and also demonstrates his ideas of problems in society (illiteracy, etc.)
Quote
"Frankly, it could get a little stale how Dad, within minutes, could elicit such worldwide acclaim. Sure- I was the first person to stand up and throw him roses, shout, "Bravo, man, bravo!" But sometimes I couldn't help but feel Dad was an opera diva who garnered reverential ratings even when he was too lazy to higt the high notes...; something about him seized everyone, regardless of the performance" (112). I really liked this quote because it shows a lot of Blue's character. She really seems to rely upon her father almost has her star to pull out for others to admire, and so she takes a rather protective stance on his praise in the quote as if she is the only one she can stand doing it. It also shows that she perhaps isn't completely happy just being his daughter, instead of her own character, her own star.
Theme
Sometimes one must delve deeper to find the truth.
Monday, November 12, 2007
"Special Topics in Calamity Physics" Post 1b
When I first started reading “Special Topics in Calamity Physics”, I was completely awed by the number and breadth of things referenced. In simply the first two pages, Blue talks of Mozart, Matisse, Churchill, Che Guevara, James Bond, Henry Higgins and Eliza from Pygmalion or My Fair Lady, The Aeneid, and even a takes a quote from J.B. Tower: “death is ‘seeing everything that has ever existed all at once’”. Pretty intense for a first two pages. A review of the novel from Publishers Weekly states: “Pessl's showy (often too showy) debut novel, littered as it is with literary references and obscure citations”. However, as the book continued on, the references did add to my enjoyment and understanding of the book. They definitely required some wikipeidia-ing (for example, Lepidoptera (18)) but it also forced me to recognize words that I did not understand and look them up instead of skimming over them. Also, these obscure references do add to one’s understanding of the true depth of Blue’s knowledge- she is definitely a gifted student with a wide basis of information. To gain this, the rigorous training that her dad must have put her through makes the reader question the quality of her childhood, as well as her ability to function in society. Someone who is constantly quoting page numbers and publication years doesn’t seem like an extremely social type. So in a way, the offhand way in which these figures and quotes are tossed about leads the reader to think more about Blue as a character. Also, there is the delight one feels when you realize you know what Blue is referencing already: some form of pride.
Sunday, November 11, 2007
"Special Topics in Calamity Physics" Post 1a
Vocabulary
Charles Kuralt (8): radio and television correspondent most popularily known for his "On the Road" segements, in which he traveled across America. In 1979, he became the presenter of "CBS News Sunday Morning".
RKO (55): RKO Pictures is an American film company that was one of the Big FIve during the Golden Age of Hollywood. It is most famous for stars such as Fred Astaire, Ginger Rogers, Katherine Hepburn, and Cary Grant, as well as films such as King Kong and Citizen Kane.
Figurative Language
simile: "She swooped into class and girls scattered like chipmunks and squirrels" (88). Use of the word "like" comparing the girls to chipmunks/squirrels in the presence of an eagle.
metaphor: "While most teachers hair at the end of the day resembled crusty windowsill plants, Hannah's- dark, but rusting a little in the late-day light- posed provocatively around her shoulders like Lauren Bacall in a doorway" (81). Hannah's hair obviously isn't truly "rusting" but instead displaying a more reddish hue in the evening light.
imagery: "The only sound in the room was the ice melting his glass" (72). The ice can't be melting the glass; instead, this is conjures the image of water condensing on the outside of a cold glass, as it is apt to do.
Quote
"'I'll be honest with you, Mr. Van Meer. The name's not healthy. The kids in class make fun of it. They call her Navy. Some of the smart ones call her Cobalt. And Cordon Bleu. Maybe you should think about alternatives."
"Might you have some suggestions, Miss Bergie?"
"Sure! I don't know about you, but I've always loved Daphne."' (78)
This quote shows not only the wit and sarcasm that Blue infuses into her writing, but also the persecution that she has endured as a misfit, even from her teachers.
Theme
In order to get into a good college (Harvard), you need to be amazing.
or
Things aren't always as they first appear.
Charles Kuralt (8): radio and television correspondent most popularily known for his "On the Road" segements, in which he traveled across America. In 1979, he became the presenter of "CBS News Sunday Morning".
RKO (55): RKO Pictures is an American film company that was one of the Big FIve during the Golden Age of Hollywood. It is most famous for stars such as Fred Astaire, Ginger Rogers, Katherine Hepburn, and Cary Grant, as well as films such as King Kong and Citizen Kane.
Figurative Language
simile: "She swooped into class and girls scattered like chipmunks and squirrels" (88). Use of the word "like" comparing the girls to chipmunks/squirrels in the presence of an eagle.
metaphor: "While most teachers hair at the end of the day resembled crusty windowsill plants, Hannah's- dark, but rusting a little in the late-day light- posed provocatively around her shoulders like Lauren Bacall in a doorway" (81). Hannah's hair obviously isn't truly "rusting" but instead displaying a more reddish hue in the evening light.
imagery: "The only sound in the room was the ice melting his glass" (72). The ice can't be melting the glass; instead, this is conjures the image of water condensing on the outside of a cold glass, as it is apt to do.
Quote
"'I'll be honest with you, Mr. Van Meer. The name's not healthy. The kids in class make fun of it. They call her Navy. Some of the smart ones call her Cobalt. And Cordon Bleu. Maybe you should think about alternatives."
"Might you have some suggestions, Miss Bergie?"
"Sure! I don't know about you, but I've always loved Daphne."' (78)
This quote shows not only the wit and sarcasm that Blue infuses into her writing, but also the persecution that she has endured as a misfit, even from her teachers.
Theme
In order to get into a good college (Harvard), you need to be amazing.
or
Things aren't always as they first appear.
Synopsis of "Special Topics in Calamity Physics"
Marisha Pessl's mesmerizing debut has critics raving and heralds the arrival of a vibrant new voice in American fiction. At the center of this "cracking good read" is clever, deadpan Blue van Meer, who has a head full of literary, philosophical, scientific, and cinematic knowledge. But she could use some friends. Upon entering the elite St. Gallway school, she finds some - a clique of eccentrics known as the Bluebloods. One drowning and one hanging later, Blue finds herself puzzling out a byzantine murder mystery.
courtesy of barnesandnoble.com
courtesy of barnesandnoble.com
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)